Cell phone policy for employees – Pros and Cons

Cell phone policy for employees – Pros and Cons

Whether restaurant employees should be allowed to keep their phones during a shift is a common management dilemma. Here are the pros and cons of allowing it:

 Pros of Allowing Employees to Keep Phones During Shifts

1. Emergency Access

• Employees can respond quickly to family emergencies, childcare needs, or health alerts.
• Reduces anxiety for staff who may need to be reachable.

2. Work-Related Use

• Managers and staff may use phones for scheduling, communication, or accessing apps used for restaurant operations.
• Employees might take photos or share social media content that promotes the restaurant.

3. Improves Morale and Trust

• Trusting employees to self-manage their phone use can boost morale and show respect.
• Reduces the perception of a “strict” or “controlling” workplace culture.
• Quick Communication – Phones can help staff coordinate efficiently, especially in large restaurants.
• Access to Work Tools – Many restaurants use scheduling apps or digital order systems that require phone access.
• Training & Reference – Workers can look up recipes, safety guidelines, or customer preferences instantly.

 

 Cons of Allowing Phones on the Floor During Shifts

1. Distraction from Work

• Employees checking phones for texts, social media, or videos may become less attentive to customers and tasks.
• Leads to slower service, forgotten orders, and more mistakes.

2. Poor Customer Perception

• Guests seeing staff on phones may view the service as unprofessional or inattentive.
• Damages the restaurant’s reputation and ambiance.

3. Safety Risks

• In kitchens or fast-paced service areas, phones can lead to accidents, burns, or dropped plates if employees are distracted.

4. Inconsistent Enforcement

• If some employees use phones responsibly and others abuse it, it can create tension and fairness issues among staff.

5. Risk of Misuse

• Potential for recording customers, coworkers, or proprietary information without consent.
• Risk of violating company privacy and policy standards.

Other Negative Effects

• Customer Neglect – Guests may feel ignored if employees focus more on their phones than engagement.
• Team Tension – Other employees may become frustrated if they have to compensate for distracted coworkers.

 

Best Practice: A Compromise Approach

Most successful restaurants adopt a middle-ground policy, such as:

• No phone use during active shifts (on the floor or in the kitchen).
• Phones must be stored in lockers, bags, or a designated area.
• Allow usage only during breaks or for emergencies in designated break areas.
• Managers may carry phones if required for job duties.
• Clear communication and signage to ensure consistency.

 

Sample Compromise Policy

“To provide the best customer experience and maintain a safe, professional environment, personal cell phone use is not permitted during active shifts. Phones must be stored away and may only be used during breaks or in emergencies. Managers are permitted to carry phones if used for job-related communication.”

Cell phone use during restaurant shifts can be a double-edged sword, offering both benefits and drawbacks. Here’s a breakdown:

Many restaurants have adopted cell phone policies to manage these effects, such as designated phone-use areas or restrictions during peak hours.

Enforcing the cell phone policy should be posted where employees can read them. Here is an example.

📌 📵 Cell Phone Policy – Please Read 📌 📵

To ensure the BEST service for our guests and a SAFE, PROFESSIONAL work environment:

✅ Permitted:

• During scheduled breaks only
• In designated break areas
• For emergencies (please notify a manager)

🚫 Not Permitted:

• During active shifts on the floor or in the kitchen
• At the host stand, bar, or service line
• For personal texts, calls, social media, or videos while working

📍 Phones must be stored away during your shift.

Thank you for staying focused and keeping our team strong!

— Management

 

The technology being used in our everyday personal life and professional areas are hard to separate, the genie is out of the bottle. Your policies have to be accepted by the work force you want to attract. It’s a tough job but we need to do it.

To read more great articles you can use, visit www.trnusa.com and www.trnusa.com/blog